- Home
- About us
- ILAC Activities
- Resources
- ILAC Publications
- ILAC Briefs
- ILAC Sourcebook
- Part 2 - Tools and approaches
- Chapter 6: Introduction Part 2
- Chapter 7: Innovation histories
- Chapter 9: Culture study as a tool for change
- Chapter 12: Collaborative agreements
- Chapter 13: Facilitation as a foundation skill for ILAC
- Chapter 14: Learning alliances
- Chapter 15: Institutional histories
- Chapter 16: Engaging Scientists through Institutional Histories
- Chapter 18: Horizontal evaluation
- Chapter 19: Appreciative inquiry
- Part 3 - Cases and experiences
- Part 4 - Challenges and strategies
- About the authors
- Glossary
- References
- Part 2 - Tools and approaches
- Presentations by ILAC Team
- Working Papers
- Journal Articles
- Newsletter
- Reports
- ILAC Library
- Tools and methods for M&E
- Appreciative inquiry
- Biophysical measurements
- Case study
- Content analysis
- Contribution analysis
- Cost-Benefit Analysis
- Creative expression
- Diaries, journals and logs
- Dreams realised or visioning
- Expert review
- GIS mapping
- Graphing results
- Group assessment
- Historical trends and timelines
- Horizontal evaluation
- Impact evaluation
- Benefit-cost methods
- Case studies
- Cost-effectiveness analysis
- Counterfactual Impact Evaluation (CIE)
- Difference-in-difference
- Econometric methods
- Ex-post comparison of project beneficiaries with a control group
- Instrumental variables
- Integrated partial indicators
- Mathematical programming
- Modified peer review
- Partial indicators of impact
- Patent analysis
- Pipeline comparison
- Production function approach
- Propensity score matching
- Quasi-experimental design, involving the use of matched control and project groups
- Randomization
- Rapid assessment or review, conducted ex post
- Regression discontinuity design
- Simulation method
- User surveys
- Impact flow diagram
- Innovation histories
- Institutional history
- Institutional linkage diagram
- Interviews
- Learning alliances
- Learning-oriented evaluation
- M&E Frameworks
- M&E wheel (or "spider web")
- Mapping (sketch)
- Matrix scoring
- Most significant change
- Net-Map
- Non-random sampling
- Observation
- Outcome mapping
- Participatory Impact Pathways Analysis
- Participatory methods
- Performance indicators
- Photographs and video
- Problem and objectives trees
- Random sampling
- Ranking and pocket charts
- Rapid appraisal methods
- Relative scales or ladders
- Rich pictures (or mind maps)
- SWOT
- Seasonal calendars
- Semantic differentials
- Social mapping or well-being ranking
- Sociograms
- Stakeholder analysis
- Survey
- Systems (or inputs-outputs) diagram
- Theory-Based Evaluation
- Transects
- Evaluation studies and reports
- Evaluating capacity development
- Partnership
- Seminars
- Video Room
- Links to other sites
- E-learning courses
- ILAC Publications
- Contact
- Blog
Evaluating the impact of research for development: tea in Tanzania
Sun, 08/31/2008 - 12:52 — Cristina Sette
Publication Type:
Journal ArticleSource:
Experimental Agriculture, Volume 35, p.247-264 (1999)URL:
http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayFulltext?type=1&fid=3046&jid=EAG&volumeId=35&issueId=03&aid=3045Keywords:
Evaluation; ILAC Newsletter; partnershipAbstract:
The developmental and scientific impacts of research carried out intermittently over a thirty year period on the tea crop (Camellia sinensis) in southern Tanzania are reported. It is an attempt to demonstrate to questioning donors that research can contribute, in many ways, to the alleviation of poverty in developing countries. During Phase I (1966?1972) the work was funded in large part by the UK Department for International Development (DFID), as it is now known, with the support of the tea industry in East Africa. During Phase II (1985?1991) a regional study in eastern Africa was largely funded by DFID with local field experimentation in Tanzania paid for by tea growers. In Phase III (1992?1997) the work was funded almost entirely by a consortium of commercial producers. Throughout this period, despite political and economic uncertainties in Tanzania, the close contact with industry meant that the results of the research were exploited to commercial advantage whenever circumstances allowed. These interventions enabled productivity on a unit area basis to rise over time and companies to remain profitable. More recently major investments in new projects have taken place in southern Tanzania, again supported by the results of the research. All of this has led to the creation of new jobs and to continuity of employment in rural areas that have few other sources of paid work. The financial return on the research investment, although very difficult to quantify with precision, has been immense. The science has not been neglected either. Over the same period more than 30 refereed papers have been published in the international scientific literature. These cover such topics as the responses of tea to climate and weather, including drought and irrigation. Scientists have also been trained in modern research techniques. In addition there have been ancillary benefits including the introduction of technical and management training programmes for staff in the tea industry. Frustration has been caused by the lack of continuity in funding due to changes in policies, and in the priority research topics, even within one donor organization, which have often put the work at risk. Ingenuity, patience and commitment have all been pre-requisites to ensure that the research continued. The partnership with industry has been beneficial to all the stakeholders. It has led directly to the creation of the new, commercially managed Tea Research Institute of Tanzania serving both small- and large-scale producers throughout the country. Researchers, with the support of the tea industry and in partnership with the Tanzanian Government and DFID, can continue to play a significant role in the fight against poverty. Research for development is a continuing process: it can be successful.
Sublibrary:
Evaluation
Partnership
- Login or register to post comments
- Email this page